This case relates to effective implementation of compliance policies and supervision of employees. CFA Institute Standard IV(C): Responsibilities of Supervisors requires CFA Institute members to make reasonable efforts to ensure that anyone subject to their authority complies with applicable rules and regulations. As chief compliance officer for the firm, Estevez is responsible for developing and implementing effective compliance policies and has effective supervisory responsibility over firm employees. He recognizes that hiring relatives of foreign government officials and other clients in exchange for business could violate antibribery laws. He drafts written hiring policies and a questionnaire to address these types of hires as a way to detect and prevent corrupt hiring practices.
But these policies do not apply to all categories of hires, are easily circumvented, and are not effectively enforced. Although Estevez rejects referred candidates for employment that violate firm policies, senior members of the firm’s APAC offices regularly get around the policies by hiring rejected candidates as employees of a regional affiliate that is apparently not covered by the firm’s compliance procedures. Referred candidates hired by the affiliate engage in work for the firm and are eventually hired as full-time employees at the firm. The compliance procedures thus do not effectively mitigate known corruption risks and allow APAC employees to award valuable employment opportunities to the relatives of foreign government officials as a personal benefit to the officials in an attempt to improperly influence them to assist the firm in obtaining or retaining business or other benefits. Choice D is the best response.
This case is based on an August 2019 US SEC enforcement action.